Fixed versus Variable

Tracy Head • September 9, 2024

One of the questions I am most often asked is “should I take a fixed or a variable rate”?

My answer to this question is different for each client.


My answer to this question may change based on the interest rate environment.

The last few years have been sobering to say the least. We were riding the high of historically low fixed interest rates and beginning to see them as the norm. 


Where interest rates are sitting now (mid four to five per cent) is closer to the average interest rate Canadians have paid over the last twenty years.


This week I attended a learning event and the economist that presented to the group spoke the words we have all been waiting to hear. He did qualify his thoughts with the comment that no one has a crystal ball and we’ve all seen what can happen with Bank of Canada monetary policy.

What he did say is that he feels we will see prime rate drop 1.25 to 1.5 per cent over the next year.


What does that mean in dollars and cents?


As an example, if your mortgage is $500,000 and your variable rate mortgage is priced at prime less 1.05 per cent, if prime drops one per cent this means your payment will be $283.28 per month lower.

This math applies if your variable rate mortgage has a payment that changes every month. If your variable mortgage has a static payment (payment that does not change to follow changes in prime) your payment stays the same but more money goes towards the principal instead of interest.

So it seems like variable is the obvious choice if you are finalizing your mortgage right now. 


But it may not be. 


Circling back to where I said each client has a unique set of circumstances, variable may not be the best option. 


Fixed rates for insured mortgages are hovering around 4.59 per cent (some lenders lower, some higher). For clients that are pushing to qualify for the maximum purchase price they can the one per cent difference between fixed and variable rates absolutely affects their borrowing power.


Lets say we are working with a family earning $120,000 annually. When we calculate their maximum purchase price using the minimum down payment and assuming $3,000 a year for property taxes here is the difference:

  • Using a fixed rate of 4.59 per cent we are looking at a purchase price of $525,000
  • Using a variable rate of prime less .95 per cent (5.49 per cent) we are looking at $475,000


Another consideration before choosing fixed or variable is individual risk tolerance. Do you have room in your budget if rates trend up instead of down that you will not be stressing if prime does increase?

Exit strategy is yet another thing to consider. With variable mortgages the maximum penalty you will pay if you pay your mortgage in full early is three months’ interest whereas with a fixed rate mortgage you will pay the greater of three months’ interest or your lender’s interest rate differential calculation. There can be quite a spread between the two.


If you are planning to pay off your mortgage in the next few years variable may be the route to go strictly for that reason.


And if you opt to choose a variable rate mortgage then decide you are not comfortable with potential changes, or if a few years in the fixed rates are far more attractive you can convert from a variable to a fixed rate mortgage. Win-win.


Deciding whether to go fixed or variable is absolutely an individual decision for all of the reasons above.


When the economist was asked whether he would choose a fixed or a variable mortgage himself right now there was no hesitation whatsoever. 


“Variable all day long” was his answer.



It will be interesting to see where rates are a year from now.

Tracy Head

Mortgage Broker

GET STARTED
By Tracy Head April 21, 2025
Not all lenders are created equal Just as no two clients are the same, not all lenders are created equal. For the majority of clients getting the best interest rate is their primary concern. For me as a broker it is as important to find a lender that provides a smooth process from start to finish and excellent customer service once a mortgage has finalized. What do I mean by this? When new lenders pop into the mortgage market they often offer low interest rates or better compensation to encourage mortgage brokers to send files their way. Sometimes these new lenders are amazing, and sometimes not as much. Once in a while more established lenders will offer brilliant rates in order to increase the number of mortgages they have on the go. We see lenders float in and out of the competitive rate market based on how much money they have available to lend at any given time. While this can be great for clients, it can also be a nightmare. If a lender does offer rates much lower than other lenders they end up flooded with applications. They may or may not have the staff / staff with expertise to handle larger volumes and increased time pressures. If we are working on a refinance with flexible dates this isn’t necessarily a problem. If we are working on a purchase application with deadlines this can become stressful for all involved. On top of that lenders have different processes for handling the legal paperwork that goes to your lawyer’s office. Some lenders handle everything in-house and have very responsive teams to handle getting the documents to your lawyer and addressing any changes that need to be made. Other lenders hire third-party service providers to produce their documents and this adds an extra day or two to the process. As a broker I try to learn about my clients’ longer term plans and find the right fit lender-wise. I look at lenders’ policies for portability, pre-payment options, flexibility with respect to their guidelines, broker support, and equally as important client service experience after the mortgage finalizes. Does the lender have a portal? Will they allow me as a broker to help my clients or do they require clients to work with them directly for any changes? We sent applications to two newer lenders over the last month because they had fantastic rate specials available. Both files ended up being very stressful as we were down to the wire waiting for mortgage instructions to be sent to the clients’ respective lawyers. I prefer not to have to deal with last-minute stress on my files.  Rate is of course incredibly important to your long-term financial health. In my mind a smooth process before and after your purchase or refinance is also important. There are many considerations that go into choosing the right package for our clients. My recommendation one day may change the next depending on both your situation and what I am seeing behind the scenes with various lenders. I hope you had a beautiful Easter weekend!!
By Tracy Head March 28, 2025
In an ideal situation I have some time upfront to work with clients on their pre-approval. I like to go over what to expect in terms of both the process and what to expect in terms of closing costs when they have an accepted offer on a home. We usually talk about potential expenses like property transfer tax, an appraisal, a home inspection, home insurance, and legal fees. This time of year we also talk about upcoming property taxes for anything they are purchasing before July 1st. I think human nature is that we want to minimize our expenses and make sure we are getting the most bang for our buck. There are a few areas of cross-over where I anticipate the clients’ realtor will be speaking to them about items like the requirement to organize home insurance and the importance of a home inspection. In practice I think most realtors encourage their buyers to move forward with a home inspection because they want to ensure clients are not buying any surprises that will create headaches down the road. Sometimes clients are buying privately and are not represented. In those cases I always urge them to include a home inspection as one of their conditions. I have had clients question the need for a home inspection, particularly if they are buying a condo or a new build. Two recent examples have popped up that reinforce for me the importance of a home inspection: - We are working with a lovely first-time home buyer in the lower mainland. Her budget isn’t huge so she has been waiting and watching for the right property to come up, and for her offer to be the one chosen. The stars aligned for her last week. Her financing was approved and all of the financing conditions were signed off by the lender. We were doing a happy dance for her and had a rude awakening the day she did her home inspection. The home inspector found an ongoing leak in the kitchen that has created a soft wall which is indicative of a bigger problem. On a surface level the kitchen is beautiful and relatively recently updated. As a first-time home buyer with no family nearby our client was thrilled by the aesthetics of this condo, then devastated by the potentially expensive work needed to repair / rectify the damage. - The second situation really caught us by surprise. We have clients on Vancouver Island who have an accepted offer on a brand-new home that has never been lived in. They did choose to invest in a home inspection and we are so glad they did. It turns out that somehow some of the larger windows were installed incorrectly and this has created damage to the windows and a leak in one corner. Again, with a new build the temptation would often be to skip the home inspection. Yes, any issues with this home will be covered by warranty. Having the home inspection done and being aware of the issues upfront gives them a lot more power with respect to having these defects repaired quickly. Now that I’ve driven that point home, its important to know that not all home inspectors are created equal. Do your due diligence – look at reviews, look at the home inspector’s qualifications and length of time / experience doing home inspections. Going with the cheapest option is not always the best option.  Buying a home is the biggest investment you will likely make. Trying to save a few hundred dollars upfront may end up costing you thousands of dollars and sleepless nights down the road. Save yourself the pain and aggravation of hidden issues in your home.